1. Home
  2. Overheard
  3. Research
  4. Your website gets cited. Your competitor gets…

OverheardResearch

Your website gets cited. Your competitor gets recommended.

Nike's own website was cited in 22% of the running-shoe answers we collected, more than any other brand's site. Nike was named first in 6%. Brooks's site was cited in 9%, and Brooks was named first in 33%.

  • Searchistry team
  • 8 minute read
The short answer

Being cited and being recommended are different things. In our answers, a brand's own website being cited didn't predict being named first, and only 16% of everything AI cited was the brands' own sites. To be the pick, you need to be on the other sites AI reads too.

Cited and named are different races

When an AI answers a buyer question it often lists its sources. A brand's own website showing up there feels like a win. But the source list and the recommendation are two different things, and in our answers they often pointed at different brands.

Own website citedNamed firstShare of answers

  • Salesforcesalesforce.com37%19%
  • HubSpothubspot.com36%52%
  • Zoho CRMzoho.com24%12%
  • Pipedrivepipedrive.com17%5%
  • Monday CRMmonday.com9%0%

75 answers, ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, AI Overviews, AI Mode.

Sorted by how often the brand's own website was cited. Tap a brand for its numbers.

In running shoes, Hoka's website was cited in 1% of answers, yet Hoka was named in 56% of them. In CRM, salesforce.com was cited about as often as hubspot.com (37% against 36%), but HubSpot was named first in 52% of answers and Salesforce in 19%.

AI uses your own pages for facts about you. Whether it picks you seems to rest more on what other sites say.

Being named isn't being named first, either

There's a second gap inside the answer itself. Plenty of brands got named often and still rarely came first:

Share of all the answers in that industry. “Named first” means the first of the five tracked brands the answer named.
BrandIndustryNamed inNamed first inOwn site cited in
HubSpotCRM81%52%36%
SalesforceCRM49%19%37%
Zoho CRMCRM57%12%24%
PipedriveCRM53%5%17%
AsanaProject management86%20%34%
ClickUpProject management79%29%20%
TrelloProject management54%20%11%
BrooksRunning shoes71%33%9%
NikeRunning shoes38%6%22%
HokaRunning shoes56%8%1%

Zoho CRM was named in more CRM answers than Salesforce (57% against 49%) but named first less often (12% against 19%). Pipedrive was named in 53% and first in just 5%. Asana was named in 86% of project management answers, more than any other tool, yet ClickUp came first more often (29% against 20%).

Being on the list keeps you in the running. Being first is what a buyer who reads one line takes away. They are worth tracking as two separate numbers.

Most of what AI reads isn't your website

Across every answer, 16% of the sites AI cited were the brands' own. The rest were review and comparison sites, Reddit, YouTube and forums, and a long tail of publishers and blogs. Each AI leans differently:

What each AI cited, by kind of site
The brands' own sitesReview and comparison sitesReddit, YouTube and forumsEverything else
  • ChatGPT321455
  • Gemini2269
  • Perplexity142462
  • AI Overviews123050
  • AI Mode21141846
  • Claude1580

Share of all the sites each AI cited. From the same answers.

ChatGPT leaned on the brands' own sites most (32% of its citations). Google AI Overviews took 30% of its citations from Reddit, YouTube and forums. Claude cited the brands' own sites least, 5%.

Larger studies point the same way. Pew Research Center found that Wikipedia, YouTube and Reddit together made up 15% of the sources linked in Google's AI summaries, in a study of 900 US adults' browsing in March 2025.

What AI read depends on your industry

The mix also changes from one industry to the next. These were the five sites cited in the most answers in each industry:

Share of that industry's answers that cited the site at least once.
IndustrySiteKind of siteCited in
CRMsalesforce.comA tracked brand's own site36%
CRMhubspot.comA tracked brand's own site31%
CRMreddit.comReddit, YouTube or forum25%
CRMzoho.comA tracked brand's own site24%
CRMpipedrive.comA tracked brand's own site17%
Project managementasana.comA tracked brand's own site34%
Project managementones.comOther publisher or site30%
Project managementthedigitalprojectmanager.comReview or comparison site26%
Project managementmonday.comA tracked brand's own site22%
Project managementclickup.comA tracked brand's own site20%
Running shoesrunrepeat.comReview or comparison site55%
Running shoesrunnersworld.comReview or comparison site25%
Running shoesrtings.comReview or comparison site23%
Running shoesnike.comA tracked brand's own site22%
Running shoesruntothefinish.comOther publisher or site16%

In CRM, 4 of the 5 most cited sites were the brands' own. In running shoes, review sites led: runrepeat.com was cited in 55% of shoe answers, and the only brand site in the top five was nike.com. Project management sat in between: asana.com on top, then ones.com, a review site, and two more of the tracked brands' own sites.

So the answer to “which sites should we be on?” starts with your own industry's answers, not a general list. The free AI check shows the sites AI relied on for your own buyers' questions, and What AI said has every finding from this data set.

The sites AI cited most

Answers that cited each site
The brands' own sitesReview and comparison sitesReddit, YouTube and forumsEverything else
  • reddit.com48
  • runrepeat.com48
  • youtube.com37
  • asana.com31
  • zapier.com28
  • monday.com27
  • ones.com27
  • salesforce.com27
  • hubspot.com24
  • thedigitalprojectmanager.com23

Out of all 252 answers, across the three industries.

reddit.com and runrepeat.com were cited in 48 answers each. Review and comparison sites made up much of the rest of the list. These are the pages AI read most while answering, and most of them aren't owned by any brand.

Some AIs cite twice as many sites as others

Sites cited per answer, on average
  • ChatGPT7.4
  • Perplexity7.4
  • Gemini5.7
  • Claude5.2
  • AI Mode4.3
  • AI Overviews3.8

From the same answers. Counted from the sources each AI listed with its answer.

ChatGPT and Perplexity cited 7.4 sites per answer on average. Google AI Overviews cited 3.8, about half as many.

With fewer sources behind an answer, each one makes up a bigger share of it. On Google's AI, being one of three or four sites matters more than being one of seven or eight on ChatGPT.

What AI searched for before it answered

ChatGPT and Claude show the web searches they run before answering. ChatGPT ran 59 searches for its 45 answers; Claude ran 30, one for each of its answers. A few of them, word for word:

  • best CRM software for small businesses 2026 comparison pricing features HubSpot Zoho Pipedrive Salesforce monday.com
  • how to choose running shoes fit gait running surface cushioning expert guidance 2026
  • best project management tool for remote teams 2026
  • best project management software for software development 2026
Searches as each AI showed them, from the same answers.

85% of ChatGPT's searches included “2026”, 58% included “best”, and 39% included “price” or “pricing”. 53% of its searches already named one of the tracked brands. Claude's searches were shorter, 7 words on average against 14 for ChatGPT: 67% included “2026”, 70% included “best”, and none named a tracked brand.

Put together, the AIs went looking for this year's “best” lists, and often for prices. Being on the current version of those pages is how a brand gets into the pile the AI reads, before it picks.

Those searches run on the AI companies' own crawlers. OpenAI says sites that opt out of its OAI-SearchBot crawler won't be shown in ChatGPT search answers (OpenAI), and Anthropic says blocking Claude-SearchBot may reduce a site's visibility in Claude's search results (Anthropic).

How to become the one AI names

  1. 1

    Keep your own pages specific

    Your site is where AI checks facts about you: what you do, who it's for, what it costs. Clear, current pages help most with ChatGPT, which cited brands' own sites most.

  2. 2

    Get onto the sites AI reads in your industry

    Find the review and comparison pages AI cites when it names your competitors and not you, and get listed, reviewed or mentioned there.

  3. 3

    Show up where people talk

    Reddit, YouTube and forums fed a large share of Google AI Overviews' answers. Real discussion there is hard to fake and easy for AI to find.

  4. 4

    Check each AI separately

    Each AI reads a different mix of sites, so the pages worth getting onto depend on which AI your buyers use.

  5. 5

    Get onto this year's lists

    AI searched for “best” and “2026”. Make sure you're on the current year's comparison pages in your industry, with your prices up to date.

  6. 6

    Let AI search crawlers in

    Check your robots.txt allows OAI-SearchBot, Claude-SearchBot, PerplexityBot and Googlebot. A blocked crawler can't put you in its answers.

What goes on the page matters too. In a study of generative engines presented at KDD 2024, adding quotations, statistics and cited sources to a page raised its visibility in AI answers by up to 40% (GEO: Generative Engine Optimization).

Our guide on how AI picks which brands to recommend goes deeper. In Searchistry, Pages citing competitors lists the sites AI cites for your competitors and not for you, and the Outreach agent helps you get onto them.

Questions people ask

Does getting cited by ChatGPT mean it recommends you?

Not necessarily. In our answers, Nike's site was cited in 22% of running-shoe answers, but Nike was named first in 6%. Brooks's site was cited in 9%, and Brooks was named first in 33%.

Which websites does AI cite most?

Review and comparison sites, Reddit and YouTube, and the brands' own sites. Across our answers, reddit.com and runrepeat.com were cited most, in 48 answers each. The mix depends heavily on the industry and on the AI.

How many sources does an AI answer use?

In our answers, ChatGPT and Perplexity cited 7.4 sites per answer on average, Gemini 5.7, Claude 5.2, Google AI Mode 4.3 and Google AI Overviews 3.8.

How can I see what AI searches for?

ChatGPT and Claude show the searches they run before answering. In our answers, 85% of ChatGPT's searches included “2026”. In Searchistry, the What AI searched page collects these searches for your own questions, so you know which pages to be on.

About this data

Sources

  1. Pew Research Center: Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears in the results (July 22, 2025)
  2. OpenAI: Overview of OpenAI crawlers
  3. Anthropic: Anthropic's crawlers, and how site owners can block them
  4. Aggarwal et al.: GEO, Generative Engine Optimization (KDD 2024)

Every other number in this post is counted from our own collected answers. How we collected them is in About this data, above.

See what AI says about you

The free AI check asks ChatGPT, Gemini and Google's AI the questions your buyers ask, and shows who they name. About a minute, no sign-up.